EBQ:TMP-SMX vs Placebo for Uncomplicated Skin Abscess
PubMed Full text PDF
Contents
Clinical Question
In settings with MRSA, does Trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole treatment after Incision and drainage of an abscess result in a greater cure rate?
Conclusion
Trimethoprim–sulfamethoxazole treatment resulted in a higher cure rate among patients with a drained cutaneous abscess than placebo for abscess that are successfully drained.
Major Points
Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) is a well known cause of many abscesses in the ED being the most common cause of purulent skin and soft-tissue infections.[1][2][3] Treatment for cutaneous abscesses has been incision and drainage with antibiotics generally reserved for those that also had associated cellulitis. This multicenter, double-blind, randomized Controlled Trial of 5 US EDs with >1200 patients challenges the traditional dogma of no antibiotics for simple small uncomplicated abscesses that can be drained. For abscess of median size, 2.5 x 2.0 x 1.5cm that underwent I&D and co-administration of 5 days of TMP/SMX, cure rates were 80.5% vs 73.6% with placebo and I&D.[4]
Study Design
- Multi-Center, Double-Blind RCT
- ED based; sites in Los Angeles, Phoenix, Philadelphia, Baltimore, Kansas City
Population
Patient Demographics
- Age: 35yo
- Male: 58%
- Days with skin symptoms: 4
- MRSA History: 7%
- Diabetes: 11%
- Abscess Location:
- Head/Neck: 81-89%
- Trunk/Abdomen: 20%
- Groin/buttock: 20%
- Arms/hands: 23%
- Legs/feet: 21%
- Abscess size: 2.5 X 2.0 X 1.5 cm
Inclusion Criteria
- Age >12 years of age
- Cutaneous lesion that was:
- Either suspected to be an abscess on the basis of physical examination or
- Confirmed via ultrasonography AND
- Found to have purulent material on after I&D proration
- Abscess for less than 1 week
- Size of at least 2.0 cm in diameter (measured from boarder to border)
- Deemed to be eligible for outpatient treatment per the ED physician
Exclusion Criteria
- Suspected osteomyelitis or septic arthritis
- Diabetic foot, decubitus, or ischemic ulcer
- Mammalian bite
- IVDU
- Long-term care residence
- Incarceration
- Immunodeficiency (i.e. ANC <500/mm3)
- Immunosuppressive drugs
- Active chemotherapy
- Known AIDS
- Creatinine clearance <50mL/min
- Taking warfarin, phenytoin, or methotrexate
- Pregnant or lactating
Interventions
- Intervention Group: 7 days TMP/SMX single strength (80mg TMP-400mg SMX) 4 tabs twice daily
- Control Group: Placebo
Outcomes
Primary Outcome
'Clinical cure of the abscess lesion at 'test of cure' visit 7-14 days after the end of the treatment period
- Intention to treat analysis (p=0.005):
- TMP/SMX Group: 80.5%
- Placebo Group: 73.6%
- Per Protocol analysis (p<.001):
- TMP/SMX Group: 92.9%
- Placebo Group: 85.7%
Secondary Outcomes
- New skin infection at different site:
- TMP/SMX group: 3.1%
- Placebo group: 10.3%
- Recurrent skin infection at abscess site:
- TMP/SMX group: 2.1%
- Placebo group: 3.0%
Subgroup analysis
Criticisms & Further Discussion
- The results of this study are only generalizable to the study population were most abscesses measured between 2 – 3 cm. There were however abscess >5cm with surrounding cellulitis where antibiotics are traditionally perscribed
- The number needed to treat to cure an abscess is 14 for TMP/SMX use
- Only 64.7% of the treatment group was 100% adherent with 17.2% being 76 – 99% adherent which make the results especially applicable to the ED population and giving a good estimate of actual patient adherence.
- Although TMP/SMX is not without side effect, no evidence of SJS was found in the study population.
- The cure rate was > 80% in the placebo group demonstrating the importance of adequate I&D
- Prior evidence, although possibly underpowered, had not found a statistical difference in cure rates but did confirm the finding of reduced formation of subsequent lesions.[5]
External Links
See Also
Funding
Funded by the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases; ClinicalTrials.gov number, NCT00729937
References
- ↑ Maligner D et al. The prevalence of community-acquired methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (CA-MRSA) in skin abscesses presenting to the pediatric emergency department. N C Med J. 2008 Sep-Oct;69(5):351-4.
- ↑ Pickett A et al. Changing incidence of methicillin-resistant staphylococcus aureus skin abscesses in a pediatric emergency department. Pediatr Emerg Care. 2009 Dec;25(12):831-4.
- ↑ Bradley W. Frazee et al. High Prevalence of Methicillin-Resistant Staphylococcus aureus in Emergency Department Skin and Soft Tissue Infections http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.annemergmed.2004.10.011
- ↑ Talan DA et al.. "Trimethoprim–Sulfamethoxazole versus Placebo for Uncomplicated Skin Abscess". NEJM. 2016. 374(9):823-832. [EBQ:TMP-SMX vs Placebo for Uncomplicated Skin Abscess|Bactrim and I&D NEJM]]
- ↑ Schmitz GR et al. Randomized controlled trial of trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole for uncomplicated skin abscesses in patients at risk for community-associated methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus infection. Ann Emerg Med. 2010 Sep;56(3):283-7.