Characteristics of Death Certifiers and Institutions Where
Death is Pronounced -- Fulton County, Georgia, 1991
Information from death certificates (DCs) is used to measure
health status and to set public health priorities at all levels in
the United States. However, because of limitations in the training
of physicians who certify deaths, the completeness and accuracy of
cause-of-death information varies (1-3). To develop a basis for
targeting education of physicians who certify deaths, CDC, in
cooperation with the Fulton County (Georgia) Vital Records Office,
reviewed a consecutive series of 500 DCs filed in Fulton County
(1990 population: 648,951) from April 10 through May 2, 1991, to
characterize the number and proportion of personal physicians (PPs)
(defined as physician certifiers not acting in the capacity of
medical examiners or coroners {MECs}) and MECs certifying death, as
well as other factors. This report summarizes the results of that
review.
In Georgia, DCs are filed in the county where death occurs.
The 500 DCs included 306 (61.2%) filed for Fulton County residents.
The DCs included deaths that occurred in January (three), February
(11), March (75), and April (411) 1991. During the study, 13
hospitals and 23 long-term-care facilities (LTCFs {i.e., nursing
homes and extended-care facilities not associated with hospitals})
were in operation in Fulton County.
PPs and MECs certified deaths pronounced at 23 institutions
located in the county. Thirteen institutions were hospitals; four,
LTCFs; and six, MEC offices in six Atlanta-area metropolitan
counties, including Fulton County (although the incident leading to
death may have occurred outside Fulton County, the death itself
occurred in Fulton County). The number of persons certifying deaths
in each institution ranged from one to 79. A total of 292 deaths
were pronounced in the 13 hospitals (range: 2-103; mean: 30 deaths
per hospital). Six deaths were pronounced at four of the LTCFs.
PPs certified 401 (80.2%) deaths and attributed 400 (99.9%) to
natural causes. MECs certified 99 (19.8%) deaths and attributed 70
(70.7%) to natural causes. During the study period, 273 (12%) PPs
certified 401 deaths; of these 273 PPs, 181 (66.3%) certified one
death each. Each PP certified a mean of 1.5 (range: 1-13) deaths.
The largest number of deaths (13) were certified by a PP at a
hospital for terminally ill cancer patients. Of the 99 deaths
certified by MECs, 95 (96.0%) were certified by eight medical
examiners from two counties; coroners from four adjacent counties
each certified one death. The mean number of certifications per MEC
was 8.3; the largest number of certifications by a single MEC was
20.
Of the 401 persons whose deaths were certified by PPs, 290
(72.3%) were inpatients at institutions, 84 (20.9%) were pronounced
dead on arrival at emergency departments, and 27 (6.7%) died in
emergency departments. Standard procedure at the hospital where the
largest number (103) of deaths was pronounced was for resident
house staff to complete the DC.
Reported by: R Hanzlick, MD, Dept of Pathology and Laboratory
Medicine, Emory Univ School of Medicine, Atlanta. Surveillance and
Programs Br, Div of Environmental Hazards and Health Effects,
National Center for Environmental Health, CDC.
Editorial Note
Editorial Note: Based on a meeting of experts cosponsored by CDC
and the National Committee on Vital and Health Statistics in 1991,
recommendations were developed for more accurate and consistent
completion of DCs in physician-education programs (4). In
particular, the recommendations suggested that, because most
physicians are likely to certify only a small number of deaths,
educational efforts should be aimed at physicians and institutions
most likely to be pronouncing and certifying deaths. The findings
in Fulton County characterize physicians and institutions involved
in certifying deaths in a defined geographic area and may assist in
the design of educational programs to increase the accuracy and
completeness of DCs. In particular, these findings indicate that
death-certification education efforts may be most effective if they
are hospital based and targeted to all hospitals to reach
appropriate PP certifiers and focus on the certification of
inpatient deaths from natural causes. Because results from this
study indicate that MECs certified nearly 20% of all deaths,
education efforts for MECs could improve the accuracy and
completeness of a substantial proportion of DCs.
Hospital-based efforts could include 1) training in death
certification and registration before permanent or resident
physician privileges are granted; 2) requiring physicians who
certify the cause of death to complete approved training within a
specified time after their first death certification; and 3)
training a designated group of physicians to certify all deaths in
the institution in consultation with the attending physician and
after review of the medical record and other documents (5).
References
Kircher T. Autopsy and mortality statistics: making a
difference. JAMA 1992;267:1264-8.
Hanzlick R, Parrish RG. The failure of death certificates to
record the performance of autopsies {Letter}. JAMA 1993;269:47.
Hanzlick R. Improving accuracy of death certificates {Letter}.
JAMA 1993;269:2850.
NCHS. Report of the second workshop on improving cause-of death
statistics. (Virginia Beach, Virginia). Hyattsville, Maryland: US
Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service,
CDC, April 1991.
National Center for Health Statistics. Physician's handbook on
medical certification of death. Hyattsville, Maryland: US
Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service,
1987; DHHS publication no. (PHS)87-1108.
Disclaimer
All MMWR HTML versions of articles are electronic conversions from ASCII text into HTML. This conversion may have resulted in character translation or format errors in the HTML version. Users should not rely on this HTML document, but are referred to the electronic PDF version and/or the original MMWR paper copy for the official text, figures, and tables. An original paper copy of this issue can be obtained from the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Printing Office (GPO), Washington, DC 20402-9371; telephone: (202) 512-1800. Contact GPO for current prices.
**Questions or messages regarding errors in formatting should be addressed to mmwrq@cdc.gov.
